Don’t Chase a Dead Deal Just Because You Already Told People About It

You said it was a done deal. You announced it to your buyers. Maybe even on social media. And now, it’s falling apart. This article is about that moment.

Blogs

Jun 6, 2024

You said it was a done deal. You announced it to your buyers. Maybe even on social media. And now, it’s falling apart.

The seller ghosted. The numbers changed. Or maybe your gut’s telling you it’s not going to work… but you keep pushing.

Why?

Because your ego is on the line.

This article is about that moment. The one where you’re no longer making decisions based on numbers, strategy, or logic, but on how it will look if you let go. We’ll break down the warning signs, the psychology behind it, and how to protect your business from “dead deal syndrome.”

Why We Get Emotionally Attached to Bad Deals

You don’t chase bad deals because you’re dumb. You chase them because you're human.

You already told people about the contract. You believed in the numbers. You maybe even visualized your assignment fee hitting the account.

But somewhere along the way, reality diverged from fantasy.

Here’s why investors fall into this ego trap:

  • You already committed, verbally or publicly.

  • You feel pressure to perform for buyers, partners, or followers.

  • You spent time and money on marketing, underwriting, or showings.

  • You’re afraid of looking like you don’t know what you’re doing.

  • You don’t want to admit you were wrong.

That’s not deal-making. That’s identity management.

The Danger of Letting Ego Drive the Deal

When you chase a dead deal, you take on silent risk:

  • You waste time that could go to better leads.

  • You lose credibility with buyers if the deal implodes.

  • You frustrate sellers who sense desperation or indecision.

  • You tie up capital, energy, and attention on a ghost.

More importantly, you might actually close a bad deal. And that’s worse than walking away.

Red Flags You’re in the Ego Trap

If you catch these early, you can exit clean. If not, they’ll drag you, and your reputation, through the mud.

1. You keep “massaging the numbers” to make it work
Instead of adjusting your offer based on hard data, you’re adjusting your expectations. You tell yourself the ARV is probably higher. The rehab is maybe lower. You’re trying to convince yourself more than anyone else.

2. You’re emotionally invested in closing, not in winning
Ask yourself: If nobody knew I had this under contract, would I still chase it? If the answer is no, you’re chasing validation, not profit.

3. You’ve stopped marketing for other leads
You’re so locked in on this deal, your pipeline is suffering. That’s dangerous. Dead deals love to take you down in isolation.

4. You’re defensive when someone questions the deal
If a buyer, mentor, or contractor raises a red flag and your instinct is to defend it… you’re no longer evaluating the deal. You’re protecting your ego.

What to Do When You Realize the Deal Is Dead

You’ve spotted the trap. Now what?

1. Re-underwrite the deal… ruthlessly

Strip away everything you wanted to be true.
Ask: If I just saw this property for the first time today, would I be interested?
Use updated comps. Get a second rehab bid. Check your latest buyer responses. Remove the rose-colored glasses.

2. Ask your “buy box” buyers for honest feedback

Not just “do you want it?”

 Ask:

  • What concerns do you have?

  • What number would make this interesting to you?

  • Would you close on this tomorrow if it were yours?

Their tone and hesitations will tell you more than their answers.

3. Talk to the seller, reset or exit

If the numbers are tight but not impossible, renegotiate. But do it professionally:

“Hey John, we ran into some unexpected numbers during our due diligence, and I wanted to bring this to you respectfully. We’re still interested, but only if we can adjust terms slightly to reflect reality.”

If it’s too far gone:

“John, after reviewing everything carefully, we’re going to step back from this one. I’d rather be honest with you upfront than cause a delay later. If anything changes on your end, keep us in mind.”

Leave the door open. Never burn it.

How to Talk to Buyers When the Deal Dies

Here’s the script you use when you’ve already blasted a deal, and now have to eat crow:

“Hey [Name], quick update on [Property Address], we’re backing out of that one. A couple things came up during deeper underwriting that don’t align with our standards, and I won’t push something I can’t stand behind. Appreciate your patience, we’ll have more deals coming soon.”

No excuses. No drama. Just clarity.
Your buyers will respect you more for it.

Future-Proofing: How to Avoid Falling Into the Ego Trap Again

This won’t be the last time a deal goes sideways. But you can avoid the pain by building guardrails.

Set a kill switch in advance

Decide up front:

  • What’s my walk-away MAO?

  • How many days will I try to dispo before pulling the plug?

  • What’s my threshold for rehab surprises?

Write it down. When emotion creeps in, your past self will be the one making the decision.

Never market a deal you don’t control

Until your contract is signed and verified, don’t broadcast it.
Until your title report is clean, don’t claim it's a “slam dunk.”
Until your numbers check out, don’t hype it.

This saves you from having to backpedal later.

Build a strong pipeline so you’re not desperate

Desperation is the ego’s fuel.
If you only have one deal in the works, you’ll bend over backwards to keep it alive. If you have five deals in the pipeline, you’ll let go of bad ones without flinching.

The Hardest Skill in Real Estate

It’s not comping.
It’s not negotiating.
It’s knowing when to walk away.

When you let your identity get wrapped up in a single deal, you lose your edge. But when you’re willing to drop dead weight, your entire business moves faster, cleaner, and more profitably.

Walking away doesn’t make you look weak.
It makes you look wise.

Final Thoughts

If you’ve been chasing a deal that’s quietly draining your time, energy, and credibility, let this be your permission slip to walk away.

It’s not failure. It’s focus.

The investors who win long term are the ones who know:

“Deals are like buses. Miss this one? Another’s coming.”

And the best deals?

They rarely require chasing at all.

Written By:

Austin Beveridge

Chief Operating Officer

Ready to connect with homeowners ready to list?

Define your target area, and we'll connect you with home sellers ready to list. No cold calls, no guesswork. Just show up to the appointment, and sign the listing agreement. Pay only when the deal closes.

*You will be subscribe to our newsletter

Discover

Join Thousands Of Satisfied Operators

Discover why top teams rely on Goliath to find motivated sellers. Get everything you need to prospect, nurture, and close more deals.

679

Live Users

$
23
M

Closed Deals

11
%

Satisfaction Rating

11
+

Markets Live

Discover

Join Thousands Of Satisfied Operators

Discover why top teams rely on Goliath to find motivated sellers. Get everything you need to prospect, nurture, and close more deals.

679

Live Users

$
23
M

Closed Deals

11
%

Satisfaction Rating

11
+

Markets Live

Discover

Join Thousands Of Satisfied Operators

Discover why top teams rely on Goliath to find motivated sellers. Get everything you need to prospect, nurture, and close more deals.

679

Live Users

$
23
M

Closed Deals

11
%

Satisfaction Rating

11
+

Markets Live