How to Reduce Seller Anxiety and Win the Deal With Empathy
Motivated sellers aren’t just dealing with property issues. They’re dealing with fear. The good news? You can help them.
Motivated sellers aren’t just dealing with property issues.
They’re dealing with fear.
Fear of making the wrong decision. Fear of being taken advantage of. Fear of change.
And if you ignore that fear, or bulldoze it with numbers, you’ll lose deals that should’ve been yours.
The good news? You don’t need therapy credentials to calm a seller down.
You just need empathy. And a few tactical tools to use it effectively.
This post walks you through:
What causes seller anxiety (even when they’re motivated)
How to spot the signs that fear is blocking your deal
Simple phrases that calm instead of push
A process that builds confidence with every step
How Goliath helps you deliver this at scale
What Motivated Sellers Are Really Anxious About
Even if a seller says they’re ready, here’s what’s going on under the surface:
“What if I regret this later?”
“What if I’m being lowballed?”
“What if this buyer isn’t legit?”
“What if I don’t have time to move?”
“What if I’m doing the wrong thing with the family house?”
Most of these fears don’t come out directly. But they show up, in hesitation, ghosting, or sudden backpedaling right before signing.
If you want the deal, you have to lower the emotional temperature first.
The 3 Types of Seller Anxiety (and How to Spot Them)
1. Trust Anxiety
“How do I know you’re not just another wholesaler trying to flip this for more?”
Underlying fear: Getting scammed, embarrassed, or pressured.
What to listen for:
Questions about your background
Comparing your offer to others
Wanting to talk to “someone else who’s done this”
What to say:
“Totally fair. I’d feel the same way if I were in your shoes. Want me to send a quick reference or walk you through how the process actually works?”
2. Decision Anxiety
“I just need more time to think about it…”
Underlying fear: Making the wrong call and regretting it later.
What to listen for:
Delayed responses
“Let me sleep on it” (even after multiple calls)
Repeated questions about the same thing
What to say:
“There’s no pressure on my end. I’d rather you feel confident than rushed. Want me to send everything in writing so you can look at it calmly?”
3. Logistical Anxiety
“I don’t know where I’m going to go next.”
Underlying fear: Losing control of the timeline or moving too fast.
What to listen for:
Questions about moving dates
Concerns about cleaning out or relocating
“I’m just not ready yet…”
What to say:
“We can totally work with your timeline. I’ve done deals where sellers stayed a few extra weeks or moved out gradually. Let’s figure out what makes this easy for you.”
5 Phrases That Instantly Reduce Anxiety
Use these as needed, on calls, in texts, or when delivering your offer.
“There’s no rush, let’s move at your pace.”
“Even if we don’t work together, I want to help you make an informed choice.”
“I’ve worked with a lot of sellers in tough situations, this isn’t weird to me.”
“I’ll spell everything out in writing so you never feel surprised.”
“You’ll always know what happens next before it happens.”
Calm language builds trust. And trust builds yes.
How to Build a Confidence-Based Deal Flow
Use this 4-step structure to guide sellers from anxiety to agreement:
Step 1: Normalize Their Fear
Let them know it’s okay to feel unsure.
“A lot of people I talk to are in the same boat, it’s a big decision.”
Step 2: Offer a Small, Safe Next Step
Don’t pitch the whole deal. Just guide them to the next low-pressure move.
“Would it help if I sent a simple breakdown of what this could look like?”
Step 3: Give Them Something to Hold Onto
Even if they’re not ready now, a soft offer or written overview gives them clarity and control.
“No pressure to decide today. This just gives you a reference point.”
Step 4: Stay Consistent (But Not Pushy)
Anxious sellers will ghost you if they feel pushed. But they’ll respond eventually if you check in calmly and helpfully.
“Just checking in, still here when the timing feels right.”
That tone wins more than hard closes ever will.
How Goliath Helps You Deliver Empathy at Scale
Even if you’re managing hundreds of leads, Goliath keeps your communication personal and thoughtful.
Use it to:
Tag leads with emotional tone indicators (anxious, overwhelmed, cautious)
Trigger follow-up sequences that are paced and pressure-free
Store call notes about seller fears or objections
Set reminders for low-key check-ins that don’t feel automated
Empathy shouldn’t disappear just because you’re busy. Goliath makes sure it doesn’t.
The Calm Buyer Closes the Deal
In anxious situations, sellers don’t choose the highest offer.
They choose the safest person.
Be the one who listens more than you talk. Who guides instead of pressures. Who calms instead of sells.
That’s how you close the deal, with empathy, not ego.
Written By:
Austin Beveridge
Chief Operating Officer
Ready to connect with homeowners ready to list?
Define your target area, and we'll connect you with home sellers ready to list. No cold calls, no guesswork. Just show up to the appointment, and sign the listing agreement. Pay only when the deal closes.
*You will be subscribe to our newsletter
