Filtering Serious Buyers From Tire-Kickers Using Deal History
Use transaction patterns to rank buyers by reliability.
Tennessee, Goliath Teammate
Key Takeaways
- A big buyer list is not the same as a useful one: segment your buyer list based on behavior, not just promises.
- A buyer score adds points for actions (1 for an email open, 20 for a closed deal) and subtracts them for ghosting (-5) or asking to assign your deal without closing (-10).
- A score of 30+ is high-priority, 15–29 is nurture, and under 10 is the cold list.
- Buyers fall into four tiers: Active Closers, Engaged Buyers, Infrequent or Inactive Buyers, and Ghosts, Time Wasters or Assignors.
- The ACT method filters buyers on Action, Commitment and Trust; a buyer showing fewer than two of the three is probably not worth your next exclusive deal.
If you’ve been in real estate for any length of time, you’ve likely built a buyer list.
But here’s the thing: A big buyer list is not the same as a useful one.
Just because someone asked to be added or clicked on one of your deals once doesn’t mean they’re a real buyer. Worse, sending every deal to every contact creates noise, not results. Blasting every deal hurts your open rates, weakens urgency, and wastes time following up with people who were never going to close.
The solution?
Segment your buyer list based on behavior, not just promises.
In this guide, we’ll show you how to clean, filter, and organize your buyer list so you know exactly who’s worth your time, and who isn’t.
Why does filtering your buyer list matter?
Filtering your buyer list matters because the real cost of an unfiltered buyer list is lost deals. Before we dive into the how, let’s cover the why:
An unfiltered buyer list leads to:
- Ghosting: You send a deal and get no response, again.
- Delays: You wait days for someone to “run numbers” only to hear crickets.
- Confusion: You don’t know who to call when you actually need to sell fast.
- Lost deals: While you’re chasing tire kickers, the real buyers buy elsewhere.
Smart segmentation, on the other hand, leads to:
- Faster closes
- Better relationships
- Cleaner CRM data
- More trust and exclusivity
- Less wasted time
Step 1: What does “purchase behavior” mean for your buyer list?
Purchase behavior is the set of actions a buyer takes on your deals, and not all behaviors are created equal. To filter your list, you need to know what counts as “high-value activity.”
Here are common behaviors to track and score:
Behavior | Score |
|---|---|
Opened your email | 1 |
Clicked a deal link | 2 |
Asked for more info | 3 |
Walked a property | 4 |
Made an offer (even if low) | 5 |
Signed a contract | 10 |
Closed a deal | 20 |
Referred another buyer | 10 |
Ghosted or canceled last-minute | -5 |
Asked to assign your deal without closing | -10 |
You can tweak these numbers based on your own criteria, but the principle is simple:
👉 Reward action. Penalize inaction. Track engagement over time.
Step 2: How do you set up buyer segments inside your CRM?
Buyer segments are the buckets your deals route through. Now that you’ve defined your behaviors, it’s time to create buckets. These segments will help you route deals and prioritize communication.
Here’s a sample segmentation model:
Tier 1: Active Closers
- Closed 1+ deals with you in the last 6 months
- Respond quickly and offer feedback
- Have cash or consistent funding
- Make decisions fast
- Ideal for off-market exclusives
Tier 2: Engaged Buyers
- Walked properties, made offers, or showed strong intent
- Haven’t closed yet, but close to doing so
- Worth building rapport and sending early access deals
Tier 3: Infrequent or Inactive Buyers
- Open emails and click, but rarely reply
- May have closed long ago, but have gone quiet
- Worth keeping on a drip sequence (not priority)
Tier 4: Ghosts, Time Wasters, or Assignors
- Always ask to JV, but never deliver
- Ask for info and disappear
- Rarely respond or follow through
- Keep in a “cold” list or remove entirely
You can label these segments directly in a tool like Goliath, whose CRM supports tags, or use tags like:
- closer
- warm buyer
- ghosted
- JV only
- not serious
Step 3: How do you add a buyer score to every contact?
A buyer score is a single number that ranks each contact by behavior. If you want to get more precise, use a buyer score system to rank your list numerically.
Create a column in your CRM:
- Add or subtract points based on each tracked behavior.
- Update the score automatically or weekly based on interactions.
Example:
Buyer Name | Last Deal Closed | Last Clicked | Buyer Score | Segment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Jane Investor | 60 days ago | Yesterday | 38 | Active Closer |
John Flipper | N/A | 6 months ago | 8 | Cold Buyer |
Sarah BRRRR | Never | This week | 17 | Engaged Buyer |
Rule of thumb:
- 30+ = High-priority
- 15–29 = Nurture
- Under 10 = Cold list
Step 4: Which deals should each buyer segment get?
Deal-type matching sends each buyer segment the deals its behavior supports. Once you know who's who, you can tailor deals to their real behavior, not just their claimed criteria.
Example Matching:
Buyer Segment | Send These Deals |
|---|---|
Active Closers | Off-market exclusives, urgent price drops |
Engaged Buyers | Fully packaged deals, clear ROI, scheduled walkthroughs |
Infrequent Buyers | Email newsletters, older inventory, soft follow-ups |
Ghosts / JV Only | Nothing, or use a JV opt-in form to requalify |
You’ll get better response rates, more trust, and faster closes by giving the right deal to the right buyer.
Step 5: How do you requalify buyers with a fast quiz or survey?
A short survey is the fastest way to requalify buyers when your list is old or bloated. The fastest way to clean it?
Ask.
Use a 3–5 question Typeform or Google Form. Example:
What types of properties are you currently buying?
◻ Fix-and-flip
◻ BRRRR
◻ Buy-and-hold
◻ Mobile homes
◻ Creative finance
How soon are you looking to buy?
◻ Within 30 days
◻ In 1–3 months
◻ Just browsing
What’s your typical funding source?
◻ All cash
◻ Hard money
◻ Private lenders
◻ Still working on it
Are you actively closing deals now?
◻ Yes
◻ No
If someone doesn’t complete the survey? That’s a signal in itself.
Bonus: When they fill it out, update their tags and buyer score accordingly.
Step 6: How do you automate follow-up based on buyer behavior?
Behavior-based automation sends each tier a different cadence, because filtering means nothing if you’re still sending the same message to everyone.
Use automation like:
- Daily deal texts for Tier 1 buyers
- Weekly emails for Tier 2/3 buyers
- Monthly check-ins for cold buyers
- “Still Buying?” sequences for unresponsive leads
With Goliath or any decent CRM, you can build workflows that:
- Trigger when a deal is clicked
- Delay if no reply is received
- Bump a buyer up/down based on activity
Behavior-based workflows keep your hottest buyers engaged, without you manually doing it every time.
Step 7: What “silent” signals show a buyer isn’t serious?
Silent signals are the things a buyer doesn’t do. Behavior isn’t always about what they do. Sometimes, what they don’t do tells you even more.
Opens without clicks are common: across all Mailchimp users, the average email open rate was 35.63% and the average click rate was 2.62%, based on data as of December 2023 (Mailchimp, Email Marketing Benchmarks).
Signal | What It Means |
|---|---|
Opens every email but never clicks | They’re nosy or curious, not ready to buy |
Always asks for more info | Paralysis or not serious |
Says “I’m ready” but doesn’t act | Flake or bluffing |
Suddenly stops replying | Lost interest or got distracted |
Buys from others but not you | Doesn’t trust your deals, or found better terms |
Track these patterns and adjust your segmentation accordingly.
What pitfalls should you avoid when filtering buyers?
Even with a great filtering system, mistakes happen. Avoid these:
Mistake #1: Over-relying on what buyers say
Everyone says, “I’m a cash buyer.” Few prove it. Trust behavior, not words.
Mistake #2: Sending too many emails to low-value buyers
Sending too many emails to low-value buyers hurts your deliverability, dilutes urgency, and trains them to ignore you.
Mistake #3: Ignoring old buyers who’ve gone cold
Some buyers disappear for months, then suddenly resurface. Keep soft drips running in the background.
Mistake #4: Not updating your CRM
A stale database is a dead database. Build a weekly or monthly review habit to clean and tag your list.
What is the “ACT” method for buyer filtering?
The ACT method is a simple mental model for filtering your buyer list. To wrap it up, here it is:
A = Action
Track who’s engaging, who’s clicking, who’s showing up.
C = Commitment
Who’s signing, funding, and closing deals?
T = Trust
Who has earned your confidence through performance?
If a buyer isn’t showing at least two out of the three, they’re probably not worth your next exclusive deal.
Your Time Is Your Inventory
It’s not just your deals that are valuable. It’s your time.
Filtering your buyer list isn’t just about making more sales. Filtering is about removing friction, focusing your energy, and creating a smoother system that lets you scale.
Remember: The goal isn’t to talk to everyone. It’s to talk to the right ones, at the right time, with the right offer.
Now go clean that list.